The New UAAP Residency Rule is Stupid and Selfish

The UAAP board recently passed a new rule that would require a high school graduate from a UAAP school to sit out two years before being able to play for a different UAAP school. The board can say whatever it wants to say about why it is enforcing this new rule, but it won’t change the fact that it is stupid and selfish.

It’s stupid because to be honest, there wasn’t really anything wrong with the old rule that only required students to sit out for a year (or not at all, if the school where the student came from allows it). It is the right of every student to choose where he or she wants to go to college. This new rule kind of takes that right away. There are a lot of ways to make a student stay. This rule shouldn’t be one of them.

It will also get in the way of an athlete’s development. Yes, an athlete can practice, build strength, and acquire new skills while waiting out the two-year residency period, but nothing can ever compare to real game action. Sitting out for that long will only make it more difficult for an athlete to get back to game shape.

It’s selfish because it puts the interest of the schools ahead of the interest of the students. That’s just wrong. The schools will say that they just want to protect their so-called homegrown talent. Well, they should do everything they can to make sure that homegrown talent stays without having to rely on a stupid rule.

I know some will say that in the end, it will be money that will influence a student-athlete’s decision. What if a student wants to move because the other school offers a better “package?” Well, that’s the thing. Instead of enforcing a stupid residency rule, the UAAP board should look into the “packages” that are being offered by the schools and find out why are they so enticing.

UAAP athletes are supposed to be amateurs, not pros. Schools shouldn’t be paying them for their services, but I think some of them probably are. That’s what the UAAP board should focus on instead of trying to force athletes to stay even if they don’t want to.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “The New UAAP Residency Rule is Stupid and Selfish

  1. short but sweet; you hit the nail on the head there. the UAAP board is commoditizing the HS students, as if they were investments that shouldn’t benefit other schools. which is bullshit. these are kids, students, and they never signed any contract in HS stating that their schools get exclusive rights to the skills they develop. i know this rule is trying to prevent “player-buying” or “pirating”, so why not clamp down on these problems instead of taking it out on the kids??? and as a student athlete in college, you have a small window of opportunity (more or less just 4 years) to really develop your game. cutting that short and removing exposure to top-level collegiate competition only dwarfs student athlete growth and could negatively impact the growth of sports in the Philippines in the long run. keifer ravena made some good points on this topic as well. this new rule is just very wrong on so many levels.

    1. Yep! Most of these kids really just want to play while also getting a quality education. If they feel that the school they cam from cannot give them the education that they want, then they should be free to move to a different school. It’s the schools that the board should keep an eye on, not the students.

  2. What the fuck is this rule? Changgelang mga board of governors yan. katarantaduhan ampotek. Now I understand why there’s a lot of flak shot against this stupid fucking rule. What the hell. Boycottin nila UAAP. Mag NCAA silang lahat, tignan natin. Invasion of rights na yan eh. Freedom yan ng mga studyante tapos gaganyanin ng mga tarantadong yan.

    1. It is unfair, indeed. The schools are only thinking about themselves, not their student-athletes. It’s a knee-jerk reaction from a butthurt and bitter school official.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s